From Gender-Lens Intention to Screening Logic and Monitoring | Two Funds, One Company, and the Week the Criterion Arrived

SMART IMPACT CONSULT | IMPACT EVIDENCE AND SYSTEMS | FUND MANAGER WORKFLOW
Two Funds, One Company, and the Week the Criterion Arrived
By Smart Impact Consult
Let me tell you about a company that does not exist.
It is a Nairobi-based logistics start-up. Call it Kijani Freight. Four people on the founding team, one of them a woman, who runs operations. A cap table with a founder, a co-founder, an angel and a seed investor. A good pitch. A real market.
Two funds look at Kijani in the same month. Both say they have a gender lens. Both mean it.
THE SIC FRAMING Kijani Freight is a composite built to show a pattern we see again and again. It is not a real deal, and no real fund is described. |
Fund A Meets Kijani at the Investment Committee
Fund A’s gender-lens policy lives in the investment committee paper. There is a section near the end called “Gender Considerations”. By the time the analyst writes it, the term sheet is agreed, the valuation is settled, the structure is drawn and the legal team has started on the documents.
The analyst asks the obvious questions. Who owns the company? Who leads it? What is the headcount split? The founders answer honestly. One woman out of four. She holds a small stake. The team is mostly men.
The section gets written. It says what is true. The committee reads it, nods and approves.
Nothing changes. The criterion arrived after every decision that could have used it. It described the deal. It did not shape it.
Fund B Meets Kijani at the First Call
Fund B asks four questions in the first conversation. Who owns it? Who founded it? Who leads it? Who works there? The answers go into a short log with a grade beside each one: documented, declared or unknown.
Now the same facts do different work. The associate knows on day one that the operations lead is a founder with an active role, and that her ownership is not yet on paper. That becomes a diligence request, not a surprise at the end. The fund can ask whether the cap table could be restructured at the seed extension. It can set a leadership target in the term sheet while the term sheet is still open. It can write the reporting line into the investor update from the first quarter.
Same company. Same criterion. Same good intentions. One fund could still change something. The other could only describe it.

Why the Window Closes So Fast
The pattern is not carelessness. It is structure.
Every deal stage spends options. Sourcing decides who is in the room. Screening decides who gets a second call. The term sheet fixes price and rights. Diligence checks what was promised. By the investment committee, almost everything that could be negotiated has been.
A gender criterion that enters at the end has nothing left to negotiate with. It can only be reported.
And the pipeline it inherits is already sorted. Africa: The Big Deal’s 2025 data shows all-male founding teams received 91% of funding. Gender-diverse teams got 8%. All-female teams got less than 1%. Female CEOs received 2.2% of funding, the lowest since tracking began in 2019 (TechMoran coverage).
The significance goes beyond fairness. If the funnel is already narrow at sourcing, a screening criterion that arrives at the committee is judging a shortlist that was built without it.

What the Framework Actually Assumes
The 2X Challenge criteria are useful here, and it is worth being precise about them, because they are often quoted loosely.
The 2X Criteria Reference Guide, in its February 2024 edition, sets out thresholds such as 51% women ownership, or 50% of founders being women, or 30% women in leadership, or 25% women in employment, with the leadership and employment levels adjusted by country and sector. It treats alignment as something assessed at any point in an investment, one investment at a time.
Then it does something many readers skip. It expects monitoring. Annual data collection. A commitment that has to show progress within two years on a second criterion, or the investment stops counting.
Read that again. The framework assumes you are still there in year two, with data in hand.
That is the part funds struggle with. Not the definition. The system that carries it from the first call to the LP report.
2X Global’s own synthesis, “Beyond the Tick Box”, looked at 81 investments across four development finance institutions. Its message, in short: the criteria are a floor, not the ceiling. What matters is what the investor builds around them.

Three Objections We Hear
“Founders will think we are auditing them.” Asked at the first call, as a plain question about the company, it reads as interest. Asked in the last week of diligence, it reads as a test. Timing changes the tone.
“Early-stage companies will not have the documents.” Often true. That is exactly why the grade exists. “Declared” is an honest answer. It tells you what to ask for next and when, and it tells the investment committee how much weight the claim can carry.
“This slows down the pipeline.” Four questions take minutes. What slows a deal is discovering at the committee that nobody can say who owns what.
The Screening Card
Here is what we would put on the first page of any deal file. Four questions. Evidence for each. A grade.
Who owns it? Ask for the cap table or shareholder register, by name.
Who founded it? Ask for the founder list with each person’s current role.
Who leads it? Ask for the org chart and the board or committee list.
Who works there? Ask for FTE headcount by gender, with part-time pro rata.
Then grade each answer. Documented means you have a source. Declared means someone said so. Unknown means you have not asked yet. Log the date, the source and the person who owns the gap.

THE INVESTOR TAKEAWAY The card, grades and wording are SIC’s illustrative tool. They are not a 2X publication. Check the guide for the threshold that applies to your country and sector. |
From Card to Workflow
A card is a start. A workflow is what makes it survive staff turnover.
Define. Write down which thresholds apply, and where they come from.
Ask. Put the four questions in the first call script, not the diligence list.
Evidence. Grade each answer. Keep the source, the date and the owner.
Verify. Reconcile the answers. Close the gaps, or write the condition into the term sheet. Then ask the test question: could someone outside the deal team trace each claim to a document?
Track. Reuse the same fields every year. Flag movement against the entry position. Carry it straight into the LP update.
If the fields stay the same from first call to year three, reporting becomes a by-product of the work, not a separate project.
What to Do on Monday
If you manage a fund, three small moves:
Move the four questions to the first call, not diligence.
Add a grade column to your pipeline tracker. Three values are enough.
Pick one live deal and run it through the card. See what comes back unknown.
You will learn more from the unknowns than from the answers.
None of this guarantees an outcome. A criterion can enter early and still be ignored. But a criterion that enters late is almost certain to change nothing.
The question is rarely whether a fund believes in a gender lens. It is where in the deal the lens gets switched on.
See How Your Own Process Would Look
If it arrives after the terms are set, it is a footnote. If it arrives at the first call, it is a way of building the pipeline. Our Impact Evidence and Systems work turns exactly this into something repeatable: screening logic that sits in the deal flow, and data that follows an investment from first contact to the LP report. If you want to see how your own process would look, we will walk through it with you.
Sources and further reading
Editorial verification note: Kijani Freight is an invented composite used for illustration. The screening card, grades and workflow are SIC’s illustrative framework, not a 2X publication. Funding figures come from Africa: The Big Deal as reported by TechMoran; team-type definitions were not stated in that coverage. Check current 2X thresholds in the guide before applying them.




Comments